Ok, which trade was worse:

Sori for Wilk, Sledge, Galaragga

or

Young, Gonzalez, Termel Sledge for Eaton, Otsuka, and random catching prospect.

You are encouraged to support your answer with some evidence.

Although I much preferred the Soriano trade when it went down, in retrospect it seems like a much worse trade with the benefit of hindsight. Soriano could have been a difference maker for this team. It's a tough call, however, given how useless our starting pitching has been behind Millwood and Padilla. Anyway, curious to hear some thoughts...