Book Review -- Rob Neyer's Baseball Legends
One of the neat things about having a blog is that people will sometimes send you free stuff to review. However, that also results in me feeling badly, oftentimes, because I get busy and don't review what I've been sent. With the season over, I'm going to try to fix that by talking about some books that have been sent to me.
Today, I'd like to talk about Rob Neyer's Big Book of Baseball Legends (the link takes you to the Amazon page). Rob Neyer, of course, is a columnist/blogger for ESPN, who has written several books, three of which I'm going to review in the next week or two.
RNBBOBL is the best of the three of his I've read, I think. I really got a kick out of it, although I will warn you, this book probably isn't for everybody.
You see, Neyer takes various anecdotes and stories that have been passed down through the years, many through books and articles, some from broadcsts, and, in essence, Fisks the stories -- going back through Retrosheet box scores, old newspaper accounts, etc., and determining what part of the story is true, and what is the product of bad memories or storytelling liberties.
My pseudo-sister-in-law says that part of the problem with Ben and I is that we like popping bubbles, and there is a lot of bubble-popping in this book...some stories where it turns out the tale is only about half-accurate, some where there appears to be just a nugget of truth, and some where it appears to be completely fabricated. But at the same time, there are several where there is a remarkable degree of verification that is able to be made.
Neyer's book is 352 pages, and has probably 100 anecdotes examined...its format of having each "chapter" be, in essence, a standalone 4-5 page segment makes it perfect bedside table material, as you can flip it open to any page and start reading, although I will admit that it can be a bit addicting.
With the one caveat that some might feel this takes away some of the "magic" of the game and the stories associated with it, I highly recommend this book. If you think it is something you'd be interested in, there are a few excerpts included on the Amazon page, so feel free to click on it and check it out.
0 recs |
9 comments
Comments
Your first link takes me to the player grading story.
by Kinslerhomer on Sep 29, 2008 12:51 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
I bought this for my best friend
who just got in to baseball this season, and doesn’t really have all the “stories of the game” attachments most fans do. He loved it.
by jwiscarson on Sep 29, 2008 1:12 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
Without giving too many spoilers...
…can you give us a few examples of the legends that got “Fisked”? Maybe just list 3-4 incidents that were featured without telling us exactly what wasn’t factual.
I’m sure I will be buying this book soon.
Physician: Primum non nocere
Batter: First, make no out
by Chad Crudup on Sep 29, 2008 1:21 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
the amazon page has such examples.
the preceding post was a great success.
by DSheppard on Sep 29, 2008 1:29 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
There was one...
….that I heard Eric Nadel do a “Page From Baseball’s Past” about last week, about a story where a minor leaguer who was a regular CF’er and who was barely ahead of another guy for the batting title pitched on the final day of the season, and walked the guy every time up.
Neyer goes through that pretty thoroughly, and determines it isn’t true.
And like DSheppard says, there are several examples on the Amazon page.
by Adam J. Morris on Sep 29, 2008 1:34 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
THX,,,
,,,I liked all of Neyer’s previous books so I’m optimistic about this one.
Physician: Primum non nocere
Batter: First, make no out
by Chad Crudup on Sep 29, 2008 2:17 PM CDT up reply actions 0 recs
If you choose to buy it consider
going to newbergreport.com first and clicking the amazon link. I’m not affiliated with the site at all (outside being a newsletter recipient), but its a free way to get Jamey, Scott, and the rest a little extra something for their work.
There’s my unwarranted shill of the day.
------------
:) - Obligatory smiley showing I don't mean whatever mean
spiritedness is likely contained in the preceding post
by jtts on Sep 29, 2008 5:27 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs
The Neyer/James Guide to Pitchers
That was one of my favorite things ever. I really want this book. Badly.
by philkid3 on Sep 29, 2008 6:03 PM CDT reply actions 0 recs

by 















