i would also probably think that would be the O’s Adam Jones

if he starts in the all star game. that’ll be worse than varitek.

hamilton being up there right now is a joke too.

adam jones should be top 3.

shouldn’t be hard to over take scutaro

Since the BoSox don’t have a dog in this race, they could help out.

Scratch that, I don’t want any thing to with those guys.

We have people worthy of it.

They’re close offensively with Hill having an advantage, but Kinz has been much better defensively.

Fangraphs has them tied at 22.6 RAR so far this year.

And tie goes to the home team, at least when it comes to All-Star voting, right?

the reply option beat weed.

us? you are not acting contrary to the rest of the league.

idiot

i wouldn’t start salty over mauer, and while his bat may not be top 5 at his position, his glove pushes him up there. and he’s a ranger!

He’d win that by a billion points and probably cure AIDS and SARS at the same time.

Joe Posnanski mentioned that everyone should also vote for Lastings Millege at every available opportunity.

It would be both amazing and fitting if the Natinals only representative was in AAA.

Just cause of his name.

jeter SHOULD make it as the starting SS

but hamilton doesnt deserve to start?

uhhh….

it’s a hitters challenge obviously.

Throwing, hitting for power, and running speed would all be pretty easy.

Hitting for average and especially fielding might be tough, though.

I guess you could call it a “Best Tools” competition or something and cut fielding out.

How cool would it be to see the leahue’s burners get timed on their ability to run out an imaginary inside the park homerun?

Neat.

Of course the second someone pulls a hamstring trying to leg that out or has a shoulder explode trying to win the throw competition you know it’d end real quick.

Still, fun.

I respect Medusa’s vote.

Fart.

i think it ends up being holliday — i think he heats up and makes it

also, porcello + jackson + verlander - no chance of them having 3 pitchers

Inge is a superlative defender and Young is a butcher’s butcher.

He’s terrible.

You really think Dye gets in over Nelly Cruz? I suppose it’s possible, but only cause voters are retarded. Dye is one of the worst defenders on the planet.

And I’d think if Millwood’s numbers are anywhere close to where they are now he’d get the nod over Porcello or Jackson.