Grade the Rangers (First Half Edition)
Alright, since we are at the break and since we don't play again till Friday night, I thought this would be the prefect time for us to grade the Rangers so far on their play this year. We have seen some of the local media do this already but now it is the LSBers time to give their thoughts and grades of the players, our manager and our GM (on how well he constructed this team and the draft he just finished).
In this grading, we are only going to include guys that have spent the majority of their time this season in the majors. So there will be no Julio Borbon in here or Willie Eyre. Just give the player a grade you feel that they deserve, plus if you want to add some comments on why you gave them that grade. Hopefully this will keep us busy up until Friday night when we play again. There will probably be one of these at the end of the year as well
Pitchers:
Darren O'Day
Catchers:
Infielders:
Outfielders:
Nelson Cruz
Manger Ron Washington
GM Jon Daniels
Awards/Predictions:
First-Half Breakout Player -
First-Half Surprise -
First-Half MVP -
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough...) -
Biggest Game -
Worst Game -
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) -
2 recs |
32 comments
|
Comments
I'm just playing this part....
Awards/Predictions:
First-Half Breakout Player – Feldman
First-Half Surprise – Feldman
First-Half MVP – Millwood (even though he sucked the last 2 starts, he was still pretty good)
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Davis
Biggest Game – 3 game sweep of the Angels
Worst Game – Any of the Detroit games
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – 85-76
The other sports are just sports. Baseball is a love. ~Bryant Gumbel, 1981
Grades
A:
Millwood
Feldman
Frankie
CJ
ODay
Young
Daniels
B:
Padilla
Grilli
Jennings
Hank
Ian
Elvis
Omar
Murphy
Cruz
Washington
C:
McCarthy
Harrison
Holland
Hunter
Mathis
Salty
Teagarden
Hamilton
Byrd
Jones
Other:
Eddie – D
Nippert – INC
Krush – F
First-Half Breakout Player – Nelson Cruz
First-Half Surprise – Starting rotation
First-Half MVP – Millwood
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Davis
Biggest Game – Back to back walkoffs against Seattle
Worst Game – The loss in Detroit where CJ gave up 4 I believe to ruin a steller Millwood start
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – 87-75, Davis comes back up in mid August and is the Davis we saw last year. We squeek into the playoffs by sweeping Anaheim in the last series of the year and get knocked out in 4 games by someone.
Bryan Smith (12:17:17 PM PT): Justin Smoak and Josh Hamilton. The AL West might just have found their Bash Brothers, v. 2.0.
Awards/Predictions:
First-Half Breakout Player – Nelson Cruz
First-Half Surprise – Blalock healthy
First-Half MVP – Nelson Cruz
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Davis
Biggest Game – Young’s walkoff HR
Worst Game – this whole last series in seattle
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – 90-72, win the West, feliz shines in the playoffs a la k-rod.
by Smoakin in the Boys Room on Jul 15, 2009 4:19 PM CDT reply actions
Awards/Predictions:
First-Half Breakout Player – Nelson Cruz
First-Half Surprise – The Defense
First-Half MVP – Nelson Cruz
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – KKKKKKKKKKKKris Davis
Biggest Game – Angels series.
Worst Game – All games played in Detroit.
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) -Offense kicks it in gear and the Rangers win the division with 89 games.
"I saw a soldier try to dig a foxhole with his bare hands. He didn't notice that he'd torn off all his fingernails. I got him out of there quickly; not for his sake, but for ours. Fear is poison in combat...destructive, contagious." - Band of Brothers
Grades
Pitchers:
Kevin Millwood – A
Scott Feldman – A Starter/F Reliever
Vicente Padilla C
Brandon McCarthy -C
Matt Harrison – C
Frank Francisco – A
Jason Grilli -C
C.J. Wilson – B
Derek Holland – C
Eddie Guardado – D
Tommy Hunter -B
Jason Jennings – B
Doug Mathis – B Reliever/F Starter
Darren O’Day – A
Dustin Nippert – F
Catchers:
Jarrod Saltalamacchia – D
Taylor Teagarden – C
Infielders:
Chris Davis-F
Hank Blalock-C
Michael Young -B
Ian Kinsler -B
Elvis Andrus – A
Omar Vizquel – A
Outfielders:
Josh Hamilton – C
David Murphy – B
Marlon Byrd -B
Nelson Cruz – A
Andruw Jones – A
Manger Ron Washington – A
GM Jon Daniels – A
"I saw a soldier try to dig a foxhole with his bare hands. He didn't notice that he'd torn off all his fingernails. I got him out of there quickly; not for his sake, but for ours. Fear is poison in combat...destructive, contagious." - Band of Brothers
heh
I find it amusing that you think CPP’s are a waste of time, but you’ll put out letter grades for each player.
"He will not coddle them. Nolan Ryan doesn’t coddle." - Jeff Passan
by Dirk Diggler on Jul 16, 2009 2:21 PM CDT up reply actions
If CPPs didn't get recced
and completely overwhelm the recommended fanposts everytime, I wouldn’t have a big problem with them. I’d just think they were silly.
The thing that makes CPPs pretty stupid also, is that a lot of the votes come from people who have never seen any of the players play. Its the blind leading the blind for the most part, based on other rankings they read in other scouting sites.
"I saw a soldier try to dig a foxhole with his bare hands. He didn't notice that he'd torn off all his fingernails. I got him out of there quickly; not for his sake, but for ours. Fear is poison in combat...destructive, contagious." - Band of Brothers
a few grades
Wash – A- … First place most of season.
Daniels – B… Benson over Feldman?
Elvis – A … Better than most expected, so far.
Kinsler – D … Great April, you have sucked snce then.
Blalock – B … Hank, I am giving you some slack. Don’t let me down.
Davis – K … What other grade does he deserve?
Elvis Andrus - 2009 AL Rookie of the Year
Mitch Moreland - 2009 Rangers Minor League POY
Grades
A:
Young
Cruz (nice surprise)
Millwood
Feldman
Odday
B:
Kinsler
Andrus (only because he’s a rookie)
Murphy (a long way from that 0 for 200 start)
Byrd
Blalock
Jones
Vizquel
Padilla
Francisco
Jennings
Wilson
Guardado
C:
Hamilton
McCarthy
D:
Salty (would have been a C, but his catching kinda degraded recently imo)
Davis (would have been an F, but he did hit plenty of homers at least)
Teagarden (i’m sure he’d get better marks w/ more PT)
Harrison
Holland (wanna give him a C)
F:
Benson
First-Half Breakout Player – Cruz
First-Half Surprise – Odday (who??)
First-Half MVP – Cruz
Biggest Bust– Davis
Biggest Game – i’ll take a young walk off homer for 500 alex
Worst Game – 1-3 against seattle. CJ gave up 3 in the 8th
2nd Half Prediction rangers finish 90-72
Michael Young is the next Steve Garvey.
First-Half Breakout Player – Cruz
First-Half Surprise – O’Day
First-Half MVP – Fx2 or Cruz
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Davis (with Kinsler 2nd)
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) -
Rangers win 90 games and finish 2nd.
Chris Davis is traded and never plays another game for the Rangers
Go Rice Owls!
x
First-Half Breakout Player – Scott Feldman
First-Half Surprise – O’Day
First-Half MVP – Elvis Andrus – sorry but where would we be without his defense up the middle?
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Chris Davis. Fairly obvious
Biggest Game – Gotta say the last game in the Angels sweep at the ballpark.
Worst Game – The Felix Hernandez 1-0 lead game recently. We had an ace beat and couldnt hold it.
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – Rangers call up Feliz and he is dominates which causes Holland to step his game up a bit to not be outdone. Also, Chris Davis gets recalled and starts hitting like last year. Im really pulling for sabretooth.
Awards/Predictions:
First-Half Breakout Player – Andrus
First-Half Surprise – Millwood
First-Half MVP – Millwood
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Chris Davis
Biggest Game – holding off the Angels when they almost rallied a couple months ago
Worst Game – King Felix game from the other day (CJ meltdown)
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – 2nd place finish, 5 out of the wild card
Greatest Inventions Ever? 1. TiVO, 2. Boobs, 3. Baseball
x
First-Half Breakout Player – Andrus
First-Half Surprise – Andrus
First-Half MVP – Kinsler
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Not really tough at all – Salty
Biggest Game – Closing out the sweep against the Angels in May
Worst Game – CJ blowing up in Detroit sticks out, but it’s hard to pick just one
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – Rangers finish in a dead heat with the Angels for the division, have an off-day offensively in their 1-game playoff and miss the postseason. Final record: 88-75.
"You know, I’m playing entirely too much." - Andruw Jones
"After intense analysis, I have come to the conclusion that Neftali Feliz throws fucking hard." - John Sickels
And I'm not gonna do individual players, but
Manger Ron Washington: C
Was impressed by some of his bullpen managment early, but toward the end of the first half it was same shit, different team/year.
GM Jon Daniels: B-
Showed some balls in the offseason, banishing MY from short, and swooped O’Day and Grilli away from the Mets and Rockies, but I’m not too impressed with the premature callups of Borbon and Holland, and I’m at a loss to why Benson was ever on this team and why Guardado is still here.
"You know, I’m playing entirely too much." - Andruw Jones
"After intense analysis, I have come to the conclusion that Neftali Feliz throws fucking hard." - John Sickels
I can agree
on Benson and Everyday Eddie. I guess Eddie has small value as a lefty and a clubhouse guy. I dont mind the Borbon and Holland callups. I just have a problem with how they were/are used. I guess that goes on Wash. Despite his actual age Wash is still a young manager but his game management and SOME of his rookie management decisions have been questionable
by Michael Cave on Jul 15, 2009 10:06 PM CDT up reply actions
Salty over Davis?
I guess it just comes down to expectations. I don’t think people were realistically expecting Salty’s bat to power up this lineup; the same can’t really be said of Davis.
by brettgardner on Jul 15, 2009 10:39 PM CDT up reply actions
yep
plus, while their offensive production is almost identical (Davis has a .007 edge in OPS), Salty plays at a much more premium defensive spot and has done pretty well in that position, despite doubts about his defense. I think Davis’ first half can be seen as a serious step backwards in his development, though one that can be corrected. While for Salty it seems like more of a coasting in neutral, not quite showing the overall improvement one would hope from a player his age.
by Smoakin in the Boys Room on Jul 15, 2009 11:45 PM CDT up reply actions
Eh
Salty has always been my personal favorite, so for me, seeing him suck is more dissapointing than seeing Davis suck. I never really gave a shit about him becoming an above-average defender, and .244/.296/.368 is beyond dissapointing for a guy I thought was gonna be the next Vic Martinez.
I don’t wanna say I’ve given up on him, but he’s got 812 MLB PA’s and a .255/.318/.389 career line.
"You know, I’m playing entirely too much." - Andruw Jones
"After intense analysis, I have come to the conclusion that Neftali Feliz throws fucking hard." - John Sickels
Salty has been pretty disappointing
and in most years, he’d be the lead contender.
But Salty hasn’t gotten demoted for being one of the worst players in the league and threatening to break one of the most embarrassing records in baseball.
Go Rice Owls!
Kinsler MVP?
Really? One great month does not an MVP make.
Elvis Andrus - 2009 AL Rookie of the Year
Mitch Moreland - 2009 Rangers Minor League POY
He still finished the first half leading the team in WAR.
Slump or no slump, he played excellent defense and I still think he’s the most talented player on the team.
"You know, I’m playing entirely too much." - Andruw Jones
"After intense analysis, I have come to the conclusion that Neftali Feliz throws fucking hard." - John Sickels
He might be the most talented player on the team
but he is not the best baseball player. Also, his WPA is currenlty at -0.41.
Elvis Andrus - 2009 AL Rookie of the Year
Mitch Moreland - 2009 Rangers Minor League POY
I vacillated
between kinsler and cruz for MVP. They both have been great on both sides of the ball and both have played in a lot of games. I ultimately went with cruz for his higher level of consistency and for keeping us afloat during some times where hardly anyone else was hitting. But Kinsler is a fine choice.
by Smoakin in the Boys Room on Jul 16, 2009 9:20 AM CDT up reply actions
Kinsler
BA – 7th on team
OBP – 4th
SLG – 4th
OPS – 5th
Elvis Andrus - 2009 AL Rookie of the Year
Mitch Moreland - 2009 Rangers Minor League POY
i dont think those are the most effective tools for evaluating a player's performance
jones has a higher OPS than kinsler. has he been more valuable to the rangers this year?
by Smoakin in the Boys Room on Jul 16, 2009 10:04 AM CDT up reply actions
I agree
there is no golden stat to rate a players performance. But I think it is ridiculous to say Ian has been great at the plate when he has his an astounding .225/.308/.430 since May 1.
Elvis Andrus - 2009 AL Rookie of the Year
Mitch Moreland - 2009 Rangers Minor League POY
Great might be a stretch when holding him up to the average major leaguer
but he has been great for periods, and below average for periods, averaging out somewhere around good to very good at the plate. But when you combine that with his defense and base-running, it makes him a very valuable player.
His offensive production since May 1 is ugly, but consider this: it is a full .70 points higher than elvis’ OPS for the entire season. And yet Elvis is still 5th in the AL amongst SS in WAR, still what youd consider an above average contributor. Now Ian can’t match Elvis’ defensive run-saving ability and 2B isnt as demanding as SS, but his efforts there are at least in the same ballpark. I thin the totality of Ian’s first half makes him one of our most important players. I feel like he is one of a few guys who youd least want to take out of the lineup on a given night.
by Smoakin in the Boys Room on Jul 16, 2009 12:55 PM CDT up reply actions
I am sort of on a rant against
single metric valuation of players right now. Ian just happened to be in the crosshairs today.
I certainly hope the ASB rejuvenates Ian and he comes out hitting like he did in April (or at least a >.900 ops). If not, I don’t think this team wins the division. The offense really needs to carry them in the second half.
Elvis Andrus - 2009 AL Rookie of the Year
Mitch Moreland - 2009 Rangers Minor League POY
I'll play...
Breakout player – Cruz
Surprise – O’Day
MVP -Cruz
Bust – CD
Biggest Game – CD walkoff HR
Worst Game – Almost every game in June
Second Half Prediction – Rangers stay close ‘til that last stretch of games and the final road trip. Finish in 2nd place behind Anaheim. The A’s will overtake the M’s for 3rd place. No trades are made. Feliz comes up but struggles. I jump off a bridge.
"The only good is knowledge and the only evil is ignorance."-Socrates
First-Half Breakout Player – No contest Nellie Cruz
First-Half Surprise – Elvis Andrus
First-Half MVP – Kevin Millwood
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Obviously Chris Davis but Salty deserves honorable mention
Biggest Game – FOF walkoff on last game of home stand
Worst Game – Any game played in Detriot
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – We reach 92 wins, Chris Davis comes back up Crushes like he did last year and Holland starts pitching much better.
I've won the same lifetime achievement award twice....yes I'm the Most Interesting Man in the World
First-Half Breakout Player – Frankie Francisco
First-Half Surprise – Elvis Andrus
First-Half MVP – CJ Wilson
Biggest Bust (yeah, this will be tough…) – Brandon McCarthy
Biggest Game – 5/4/09, Elvis makes an awesome play to get Johjima in the bottom of the 9th.
Worst Game – Memorial Day
2nd Half Prediction (either a final record, bold prediction, promotion, trade, surprise, etc.) – Division winners with 92 wins.

by 





















