It looks like, just as in the A.L., the guy who was head-and-shoulders above everyone else in the N.L., Roger Clemens, will get shafted.
And Andy Pettitte, the second-best pitcher in the N.L. this season, isn't even in the discussion.
Update [2005-11-10 15:29:2 by Adam J. Morris]: -- Carpenter wins.
Willis is second, Clemens a distant third, Oswalt fourth, and Chad Cordero and Andy Pettitte tie for 5th, each with one third place vote.